click to enable zoom
loading...
We didn't find any results
open map
View
Roadmap Satellite Hybrid Terrain
My Location Fullscreen Prev Next
Your search results

Bay Island, Virginia Beach, VA Homes For Sale & Real Estate

View Over 5000 Homes For Sale
New Listings Every 15 Minutes
Jake Maines, Virginia Beach Realtor
Not sure which neighborhood?
Find your fit in 2 minutes
Price
Beds
Baths
Save Search
Advanced Search

No Results Found.

Why Bay Island, Virginia Beach,
VA Homes For Sale?

Bay Island, Virginia Beach, VA, sits in the North Great Neck area of the city along Long Creek and Broad Bay, and it is exactly what the name says, an island connected to the mainland by a single bridge. Nearly every home here is close to the water, and a good share of them sit right on it with docks. Homes on Bay Island range widely in style and value, from mid century houses on the interior streets to large waterfront properties. For those who want a waterfront setting, a boat out back and a neighborhood that feels miles from the city even though it is right around the corner, Bay Island is worth a look.

What to Expect in Bay Island

Mid-century streets and waterfront estates

The luxury waterfront properties come with docks and wide bay views, and the waterfront lots carry a big premium, so the price range is wide. Golf is close, and so is Chic’s Beach. For the same on-the-water living, waterfront homes in Alanton, Bay Colony homes for sale and Great Neck waterfront listings are worth a look.

Getting Around Bay Island

One bridge on and off

Bay Island is between Long Creek and Broad Bay, both offshoots of the Lynnhaven River, and the West Great Neck bridge connects it to the mainland. Because you are on an island, it takes a few extra minutes to get anywhere, but most residents find the privacy worth it. Fort Story is about 15 minutes, Little Creek about 20, NAS Oceana about 25 and downtown Norfolk about 35.

Flood Zones and Insurance in Bay Island

What to check before you buy

Because nearly every street is close to the water, roughly a quarter of the recent sales we checked on Bay Island sat in a FEMA flood zone as of November 2026, and the waterfront homes make up most of them. Check the city flood map, ask for an elevation certificate and get a flood insurance quote before you make an offer. Bay Island has an active homeowners association, so ask for the dues and the rules too. To look up reported incidents near an address, use the Virginia Beach Police Department online crime map.

Schools in Bay Island

Check the zone for every address

Homes on Bay Island are zoned for John B. Dey Elementary School, Great Neck Middle School and Frank W. Cox High School, all part of Virginia Beach City Public Schools. Zones can change, so confirm the assigned schools for any address with the VBCPS school locator before you make an offer.

Lifestyle and Amenities in Bay Island

The association and the Garden Club

Bay Island gives you privacy and bay views without being far from anything. The homeowners association is fairly active, and community groups like the Garden Club keep the entrance and the common areas looking sharp.

Shopping and Dining in Bay Island

Lynnhaven Colony Shoppes and Town Center

Lynnhaven Colony Shoppes is just off the island, and Town Center of Virginia Beach is about 20 minutes away, with restaurants and shops at both.

Parks and Recreation in Bay Island

First Landing, Chic’s Beach and golf

Bay Island is right on the water, and First Landing State Park and the bay beaches at Chic’s Beach are a short drive up Great Neck Road. Several golf courses are nearby as well. To see what is for sale, talk with Virginia Beach Realtor Jake Maines, or compare it with the rest of the Virginia Beach listings.

Updated November 2026

Get The Newest
Bay Island, Virginia Beach Homes For Sale

Register A Free Account
 

Get an email the moment a new Bay Island listing hits the market or a price changes.

Homes For Sale Near Bay Island, Virginia Beach, VA

Questions About Bay Island, Virginia Beach, VA Homes For Sale? Contact Jake

When you work with me as your real estate agent in Virginia Beach, you get a strong negotiator who knows the local market and takes care of the details. I put your needs first through every step, from the first showing to closing, and I stay with it until we find the right house. 

Contact Us

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Name(Required)

Compare Listings

Before You Go,
Let Me Take
The Searching Off
Your Plate?
Before You Go, Let Me Take The Searching Off Your Plate?

Tell me what you’re looking for, I’ll send homes that fit and some you probably haven’t seen, so you don’t have to keep coming back to search.

Tell me what you’re looking for, I’ll send homes that fit and some you probably haven’t seen, so you don’t have to keep coming back to search.

Let Jake Find My Home
I’ll Only Send You Homes Worth Your Time And The Newest Listings As They Hit The MLS
You Don't Have
To Keep Searching!

Tell me what you’re looking for. I’ll use my local knowledge to find a perfect fit and send you homes that match your criteria perfectly. Plus a few you wouldn’t have found on your own.

Jake Maines Headshots March 2026-72
Jake Maines Headshots March 2026-72

Tell me what you’re looking for. I’ll use my local knowledge to find a perfect fit and send you homes that match your criteria perfectly. Plus a few you wouldn’t have found on your own.

Find Homes For Me
I’ll Keep It Relevant To What You Want Plus The Newest Listings As They Hit The MLS
Let Jake Handle
The Searching

Let me know what you’re looking for, and I’ll send you homes that fit.

And, some you probably haven’t seen.


Let me do the
searching for you!

Let me know what you’re looking for, and I’ll send you homes that fit.

And, some you probably haven’t seen.


Let me do the searching for you!

Jake Maines Headshots March 2026-72
Find Me Homes That Fit!
I'll Send You Homes Worth Your Time
And The Newest Listings As They Hit The MLS